• Weil Nutrition Corner
  • Meet Dr. Weil
  • Origins
  • Healthy Aging
  • Marketplace
  • Podcasts
  • Accessibility
  • Subscribe
Dr. Weil Logo Dr. Weil Logo Weil™ Andrew Weil, M.D.
  • Health & Wellness
    Health & Wellness
    Body, Mind & Spirit
    • Addiction
    • Allergy & Asthma
    • Autoimmune Disorders
    • Back Pain
    • Bone & Joint
    • Cancer
    • Colds & Flu
    • Dental & Oral
    • Diabetes
    • Disease & Disorders
    • Ears, Nose, & Throat
    • Feet
    • Gastrointestinal
    • Hair, Skin, & Nails
    • Headache
    • Heart
    • Insects & Parasites
    • Liver & Kidney
    • Mental Health
    • Pregnancy & Fertility
    • Respiratory
    • Sexual Health
    • Sleep Issues
    • Stress & Anxiety
    • Vision
    Balanced Living
    • Exercise & Fitness
    • Gardening
    • Healthy Home
    • Healthy Living
    • Meditation & Inspiration
    • Meet Dr. Weil
    • Pets & Pet Care
    • Technology
    • Wellness Therapies
    Health Centers
    • Aging Gracefully
    • Children
    • Condition Care Guide
    • Men
    • Women
  • Diet & Nutrition
    Diet & Nutrition
    Anti-Inflammatory Diet & Pyramid
    Cooking & Cookware
    Diets & Weight Loss
    Food Safety
    Nutrition
    Recipes
  • Vitamins, Supplements & Herbs
    Vitamins, Supplements & Herbs
    Herbs
    Supplements & Remedies
    Vitamins
  • Ask Dr. Weil
  • Blogs
    Blogs
    Bulletins
    Health Tips
    Spontaneous Happiness
  • Mushrooms
  • Sleep
Press "Enter" to search
Dr. Weil Logo Weil™ Andrew Weil, M.D.
  • Health & Wellness
    Health & Wellness
    Body, Mind & Spirit
    • Addiction
    • Allergy & Asthma
    • Autoimmune Disorders
    • Back Pain
    • Bone & Joint
    • Cancer
    • Colds & Flu
    • Dental & Oral
    • Diabetes
    • Disease & Disorders
    • Ears, Nose, & Throat
    • Feet
    • Gastrointestinal
    • Hair, Skin, & Nails
    • Headache
    • Heart
    • Insects & Parasites
    • Liver & Kidney
    • Mental Health
    • Pregnancy & Fertility
    • Respiratory
    • Sexual Health
    • Sleep Issues
    • Stress & Anxiety
    • Vision
    Balanced Living
    • Exercise & Fitness
    • Gardening
    • Healthy Home
    • Healthy Living
    • Meditation & Inspiration
    • Meet Dr. Weil
    • Pets & Pet Care
    • Technology
    • Wellness Therapies
    Health Centers
    • Aging Gracefully
    • Children
    • Condition Care Guide
    • Men
    • Women
  • Diet & Nutrition
    Diet & Nutrition
    Anti-Inflammatory Diet & Pyramid
    Cooking & Cookware
    Diets & Weight Loss
    Food Safety
    Nutrition
    Recipes
  • Vitamins, Supplements & Herbs
    Vitamins, Supplements & Herbs
    Herbs
    Supplements & Remedies
    Vitamins
  • Ask Dr. Weil
  • Blogs
    Blogs
    Bulletins
    Health Tips
    Spontaneous Happiness
  • Mushrooms
  • Sleep
  • Weil Nutrition Corner
  • Meet Dr. Weil
  • Origins
  • Healthy Aging
  • Marketplace
  • Podcasts
  • Accessibility
  1. Home
  2. Health & Wellness
  3. Body, Mind & Spirit
  4. Cancer

Choosing Breast Cancer Surgery?

I have a friend diagnosed with early breast cancer. She has decided on a mastectomy and wants to have her unaffected breast removed, too, even though her doctor says there’s little chance of cancer developing there. Is that really the case?

Andrew Weil, M.D. | July 4, 2016

choosing breast cancer surgery
2 min

Clinical evidence suggests the risk of breast cancer occurring in the unaffected breast of women diagnosed in the early stages of the disease is low. However, many women appear to be unconvinced, since rates of removal of the unaffected breast have more than tripled, from 3.9 percent in 2002 to 12.7 percent in 2012.

A new study of this trend from Brigham and Women’s Hospital (BWH) in Boston found no survival benefit as a result of “contralateral prophylactic mastectomy” (CPM), the medical term for removing an unaffected breast. The researchers noted that CPM may have a survival benefit only for women at high risk of breast cancer, such as those with a BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation, a strong family history of breast or ovarian cancer, or a personal history of radiation to the lymph node areas in the neck, chest, and under the arms, given as treatment for Hodgkin’s lymphoma. Radiation treatment in that area increases the risk of breast cancer later in life. The researchers found that only one-third of women who opted for contralateral prophylactic mastectomy had one or more of these risk factors.

To arrive at their conclusions, the investigators analyzed data from 496,488 women who had been diagnosed with stage-1 to stage-3 breast cancer. The BWH team followed each of these women for 8.25 years between 1998-2012. They found that 59.6 percent had breast-conserving surgery (lumpectomy), 33.4 percent had the affected breast removed (unilateral mastectomy) and seven percent underwent CPM. Comparing women who had breast-conserving therapy with those who had CPM, they saw no significant improvement in survival.

Aside from not offering a survival advantage, a contralateral prophylactic mastectomy is not a benign procedure. Its risks including prolonged recovery time, increased risk of operative complications, the possible need for repeat surgery, and effects on self-image as well as higher cost.

Some women may be choosing to undergo CPM because of a desire to minimize breast asymmetry through reconstruction, which has become increasingly available. The researchers cited an increase in reconstruction rates among women who have CPM from 35.3 percent to 55.4 percent during the study period. Compared to women choosing lumpectomy or mastectomy, those who opted for CPM were more likely to be white, the investigators noted.

Regardless of cosmetic considerations and the availability of breast reconstruction, the BWH team noted that women who chose CPM reported that one of the most important factors in making the decision was a desire to extend life. This suggests that many women may not fully understand the low risk of developing cancer in the unaffected breast. It also shows a need for comprehensive counseling during the surgical decision-making process.

Andrew Weil, M.D.

Source:
Mehra Golshan. “Growing Use of Contralateral Prophylactic Mastectomy Despite no Improvement in Long-term Survival for Invasive Breast Cancer.” Annals of Surgery, 2016; 1 DOI:10.1097/SLA.0000000000001698

Advertisement
Related Weil Products

Dr. Weil on Healthy Aging for Cancer Support

Dr. Weil on Healthy Aging – Do you or a loved one have cancer? The Dr. Weil on Healthy Aging online guide has simple, effective preventive health information and tools including an exclusive version of Dr. Weil’s Anti-Inflammatory Food Pyramid. Join today and get 14 days free!
Get Started
Dr. Weil on Healthy Aging

Start Your 14-Day Free Trial

Free Newsletters

Stay Connected With Dr. Weil

Anti-Inflammatory Diet

Follow Dr. Weil’s Food Pyramid

Get Dr Weils Newsletter Updates

Exclusive Lifestyle, Nutrition & Health Advice

Dr. Weil's FREE health living advice delivered to you!

By clicking "Subscribe," you agree to the DrWeil.com Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy. You also agree to receive emails from DrWeil.com, and you may opt out of DrWeil.com subscriptions at any time.

Trending Now

3-d mammograms
Cancer

3-D Mammograms?

a better test for breast cancer
Cancer

A Better Test For Breast Cancer?

HDL Cholesterol & LDL Cholesterol: What They Mean | Heart Health | Andrew Weil, M.D.
Cancer

A Blood Test for Breast Cancer?

a test for ovarian cancer
Cancer

A Test for Ovarian Cancer?

Dr. Weil Logo Weil™ Andrew Weil, M.D.
Dr. Weil's Signature

Exclusive Lifestyle, Nutrition & Health Advice

  • About Us
  • Press Information
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Accessibility

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

Information on this website is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended as a substitute for the advice provided by your physician or other healthcare professional. You should not use the information on this website for diagnosing or treating a health problem or disease, or prescribing any medication or other treatment. Any third party offering or advertising on this website does not constitute an endorsement by Andrew Weil, M.D. or Healthy Lifestyle Brands.

© Copyright 2025 Healthy Lifestyle Brands, LLC. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited. www.drweil.com