advertisement



Q & A Library


Print this page | Sign up for free e-bulletins
 | Bookmark This Page

Q
Do Antioxidants Limit Exercise Benefits?

What's your take on the study that found that antioxidants work against your body's natural anti-oxidative capability after exercise?

A
Answer (Published 12/21/2009)

You're referring to a study by a research team headed by Michael Ristow, M.D., at the University of Jena in Germany. The conclusions, prominently featured in the New York Times on May 11, 2009, seemed shocking. The investigators reported that young men who took vitamins C and E showed no improvement in insulin sensitivity and almost no activation of the body's natural defense mechanism against oxidative damage. They concluded that "antioxidants in general cause certain effects that inhibit otherwise positive effects of exercise, dieting and other interventions." The study was published in the May 26, 2009, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Related Weil Products
Dr. Weil's Vitamin Advisor for Supplements & Herbs - If you are interested in supplementing your diet, and want to take the mystery out of choosing vitamins, try Dr. Weil's Vitamin Advisor. Visit today for your free, personalized Dr. Weil's Vitamin Advisor Recommendation.

I discussed this study with Jeffrey Blumberg, Ph.D., director of the Antioxidants Research Laboratory at the Jean Mayer USDA Human Nutrition Research Center on Aging at Tufts University. He took issue with the authors' omission of any mention of the large number of studies that came to markedly different conclusions from theirs. Many peer-reviewed articles have shown a benefit from supplemental vitamins C and E taken together or separately during exercise, including better control of blood sugar.

Dr. Blumberg also pointed out that the results of the Ristow study combine findings from an open label (non-blinded) trial and a randomized clinical trial with no indication of which data came from which study - a "violation of appropriate and fair study design and of detailed and full reporting of the results."

Beyond that, Dr. Blumberg took issue with comment from Dr. Ristow featured in the New York Times to the effect that supplementary (my emphasis) vitamins C and E are harmful, but these same vitamins in food present no threat because of the "many other substances [foods] contain [that] presumably outweigh any negative effect." Dr. Ristow offered no explanation of this theory or any identification of the ‘other substances,' said Dr. Blumberg.

More disturbing are Ristow's comments elsewhere that his study's results suggest that fruits and vegetables are healthy "despite their content in antioxidants," and that other compounds in these (foods) are responsible for their health promoting effects. This seems to suggest that Ristow believes that vitamins C and E, essential nutrients, even in natural plant foods are somehow bad for us.

In addition, Dr. Blumberg questioned this quote from Dr. Ristow in the New York Times article: "Antioxidants in general cause certain effects that inhibit otherwise positive effects of exercise, dieting and other interventions." Dr. Blumberg asked how Dr. Ristow arrived at this conclusion when in his study "he tested only one dose of two of the thousands of dietary antioxidants - which include other tocopherols, tocotrienols, phenolic acids, carotenoids, flavonoids, stilbenes, and other polyphenolic compounds - in our diet."

I agree with Dr. Blumberg's criticisms and am disappointed that the New York Times featured the study so prominently. It seems to me that both the study and the coverage of it reflect a general effort to smear supplements. Certainly, the findings do not provide a rationale for not taking antioxidant vitamin and mineral supplements.

Andrew Weil, M.D.

Creative Commons License Some Rights Reserved Creative Commons Copyright Notice
A portion of the original material created by Weil Lifestyle, LLC on DrWeil.com (specifically, all question and answer-type articles in the Dr. Weil Q&A Library) is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License.

The Weil Vitamin Advisor
Get your FREE personalized vitamin recommendation & supplement plan today!

Dr. Weil on Healthy Aging
Your Online Guide to the Anti-Inflammatory Diet. Start eating for your health - begin your free trial now.

Dr. Weil's Spontaneous Happiness
Achieve emotional well-being
in just eight weeks!
Start your 10-day free trial now!

Vitamin Library
Supplement your knowledge with Dr. Weil's essential vitamin facts. Learn why they are necessary and more.

Dr. Weil's Optimum Health Plan
Your 8-week plan to wellness.
Begin your journey today!
 

Dr. Weil's Head-to-Toe
Wellness Guide

Your guide to natural health.
Use the Wellness Guide today!

Dr. Weil's Anti-Inflammatory Diet Food Pyramid
Our interactive tool can help improve overall health through diet.

Condition Care Guide
Learn about health conditions from acne to vertigo, and Dr. Weil's view of the best treatment options for each.

Healthy Recipes
Discover a treasure trove of healthy, healing foods and creative, delicious ways to prepare them.

Q&A Library
Over 2,000 questions from you
and their corresponding answers
from Dr. Weil.

 
Copyright © 2014 Weil Lifestyle, LLC
Information on this web site is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended as a substitute for the advice provided by your physician or other healthcare professional. You should not use the information on this web site for diagnosing or treating a health problem or disease, or prescribing any medication or other treatment.

Ad Choice
Advertising Notice

This Site and third parties who place advertisements on this Site may collect and use information about your visits to this Site and other websites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services of interest to you. If you would like to obtain more information about these advertising practices and to make choices about online behavioral advertising, please click here